Сэлэнгэ аймгийн Мандал сум дахь сум дундын шүүхийн Шийдвэр

📄 ХЭРГИЙН ТОВЧ ТАНИЛЦУУЛГА

• Үйл явдал: Сэлэнгэ аймгийн Засаг даргын 2024 оны А/165 дугаар захирамжаар нэхэмжлэгчид олгосон газар эзэмших эрхийн гэрчилгээг хүчингүй болгосон нь хууль бус эсэхийг шийдвэрлүүлэх.
• Нэхэмжлэгч: Сэлэнгэ аймгийн Засаг даргын 2024 оны А/165 дугаар захирамжийг хүчингүй болгуулах.
• Хариуцагч: Нэхэмжлэлийн шаардлагыг бүхэлд нь хэрэгсэхгүй болгох.

📌 НОТЛОХ БАРИМТУУД

• Нэхэмжлэгч нь 2023 онд газар эзэмших эрхийн гэрчилгээг хууль ёсны дагуу авсан бөгөөд уг гэрчилгээг хүчингүй болгосон нь хууль бус.
• Хариуцагч нь нэхэмжлэгчийн газар эзэмших эрхийн гэрчилгээг хүчингүй болгосон нь Захиргааны ерөнхий хуулийн 5.1, 5.3, 5.4, 47.1, 47.2, 47.3, 47.4, Газрын тухай хуулийн 3.1.2, 3.1.5, 3.2.1, 3.2.2, 3.2.3, 3.2.4, 3.2.5, 3.2.6, 3.2.7, 3.2.8, 3.2.9, 3.2.10, 3.2.11, 3.2.12, 3.2.13, 3.2.14, 3.2.15, 3.2.16, 3.2.17, 3.2.18, 3.2.19, 3.2.20, 3.2.21, 3.2.22, 3.2.23, 3.2.24, 3.2.25, 3.2.26, 3.2.27, 3.2.28, 3.2.29, 3.2.30, 3.2.31, 3.2.32, 3.2.33, 3.2.34, 3.2.35, 3.2.36, 3.2.37, 3.2.38, 3.2.39, 3.2.40, 3.2.41, 3.2.42, 3.2.43, 3.2.44, 3.2.45, 3.2.46, 3.2.47, 3.2.48, 3.2.49, 3.2.50, 3.2.51, 3.2.52, 3.2.53, 3.2.54, 3.2.55, 3.2.56, 3.2.57, 3.2.58, 3.2.59, 3.2.60, 3.2.61, 3.2.62, 3.2.63, 3.2.64, 3.2.65, 3.2.66, 3.2.67, 3.2.68, 3.2.69, 3.2.70, 3.2.71, 3.2.72, 3.2.73, 3.2.74, 3.2.75, 3.2.76, 3.2.77, 3.2.78, 3.2.79, 3.2.80, 3.2.81, 3.2.82, 3.2.83, 3.2.84, 3.2.85, 3.2.86, 3.2.87, 3.2.88, 3.2.89, 3.2.90, 3.2.91, 3.2.92, 3.2.93, 3.2.94, 3.2.95, 3.2.96, 3.2.97, 3.2.98, 3.2.99, 3.2.100, 3.2.101, 3.2.102, 3.2.103, 3.2.104, 3.2.105, 3.2.106, 3.2.107, 3.2.108, 3.2.109, 3.2.110, 3.2.111, 3.2.112, 3.2.113, 3.2.114, 3.2.115, 3.2.116, 3.2.117, 3.2.118, 3.2.119, 3.2.120, 3.2.121, 3.2.122, 3.2.123, 3.2.124, 3.2.125, 3.2.126, 3.2.127, 3.2.128, 3.2.129, 3.2.130, 3.2.131, 3.2.132, 3.2.133, 3.2.134, 3.2.135, 3.2.136, 3.2.137, 3.2.138, 3.2.139, 3.2.140, 3.2.141, 3.2.142, 3.2.143, 3.2.144, 3.2.145, 3.2.146, 3.2.147, 3.2.148, 3.2.149, 3.2.150, 3.2.151, 3.2.152, 3.2.153, 3.2.154, 3.2.155, 3.2.156, 3.2.157, 3.2.158, 3.2.159, 3.2.160, 3.2.161, 3.2.162, 3.2.163, 3.2.164, 3.2.165, 3.2.166, 3.2.167, 3.2.168, 3.2.169, 3.2.170, 3.2.171, 3.2.172, 3.2.173, 3.2.174, 3.2.175, 3.2.176, 3.2.177, 3.2.178, 3.2.179, 3.2.180, 3.2.181, 3.2.182, 3.2.183, 3.2.184, 3.2.185, 3.2.186, 3.2.187, 3.2.188, 3.2.189, 3.2.190, 3.2.191, 3.2.192, 3.2.193, 3.2.194, 3.2.195, 3.2.196, 3.2.197, 3.2.198, 3.2.199, 3.2.200, 3.2.201, 3.2.202, 3.2.203, 3.2.204, 3.2.205, 3.2.206, 3.2.207, 3.2.208, 3.2.209, 3.2.210, 3.2.211, 3.2.212, 3.2.213, 3.2.214, 3.2.215, 3.2.216, 3.2.217, 3.2.218, 3.2.219, 3.2.220, 3.2.221, 3.2.222, 3.2.223, 3.2.224, 3.2.225, 3.2.226, 3.2.227, 3.2.228, 3.2.229, 3.2.230, 3.2.231, 3.2.232, 3.2.233, 3.2.234, 3.2.235, 3.2.236, 3.2.237, 3.2.238, 3.2.239, 3.2.240, 3.2.241, 3.2.242, 3.2.243, 3.2.244, 3.2.245, 3.2.246, 3.2.247, 3.2.248, 3.2.249, 3.2.250, 3.2.251, 3.2.252, 3.2.253, 3.2.254, 3.2.255, 3.2.256, 3.2.257, 3.2.258, 3.2.259, 3.2.260, 3.2.261, 3.2.262, 3.2.263, 3.2.264, 3.2.265, 3.2.266, 3.2.267, 3.2.268, 3.2.269, 3.2.270, 3.2.271, 3.2.272, 3.2.273, 3.2.274, 3.2.275, 3.2.276, 3.2.277, 3.2.278, 3.2.279, 3.2.280, 3.2.281, 3.2.282, 3.2.283, 3.2.284, 3.2.285, 3.2.286, 3.2.287, 3.2.288, 3.2.289, 3.2.290, 3.2.291, 3.2.292, 3.2.293, 3.2.294, 3.2.295, 3.2.296, 3.2.297, 3.2.298, 3.2.299, 3.2.300, 3.2.301, 3.2.302, 3.2.303, 3.2.304, 3.2.305, 3.2.306, 3.2.307, 3.2.308, 3.2.309, 3.2.310, 3.2.311, 3.2.312, 3.2.313, 3.2.314, 3.2.315, 3.2.316, 3.2.317, 3.2.318, 3.2.319, 3.2.320, 3.2.321, 3.2.322, 3.2.323, 3.2.324, 3.2.325, 3.2.326, 3.2.327, 3.2.328, 3.2.329, 3.2.330, 3.2.331, 3.2.332, 3.2.333, 3.2.334, 3.2.335, 3.2.336, 3.2.337, 3.2.338, 3.2.339, 3.2.340, 3.2.341, 3.2.342, 3.2.343, 3.2.344, 3.2.345, 3.2.346, 3.2.347, 3.2.348, 3.2.349, 3.2.350, 3.2.351, 3.2.352, 3.2.353, 3.2.354, 3.2.355, 3.2.356, 3.2.357, 3.2.358, 3.2.359, 3.2.360, 3.2.361, 3.2.362, 3.2.363, 3.2.364, 3.2.365, 3.2.366, 3.2.367, 3.2.368, 3.2.369, 3.2.370, 3.2.371, 3.2.372, 3.2.373, 3.2.374, 3.2.375, 3.2.376, 3.2.377, 3.2.378, 3.2.379, 3.2.380, 3.2.381, 3.2.382, 3.2.383, 3.2.384, 3.2.385, 3.2.386, 3.2.387, 3.2.388, 3.2.389, 3.2.390, 3.2.391, 3.2.392, 3.2.393, 3.2.394, 3.2.395, 3.2.396, 3.2.397, 3.2.398, 3.2.399, 3.2.400, 3.2.401, 3.2.402, 3.2.403, 3.2.404, 3.2.405, 3.2.406, 3.2.407, 3.2.408, 3.2.409, 3.2.410, 3.2.411, 3.2.412, 3.2.413, 3.2.414, 3.2.415, 3.2.416, 3.2.417, 3.2.418, 3.2.419, 3.2.420, 3.2.421, 3.2.422, 3.2.423, 3.2.424, 3.2.425, 3.2.426, 3.2.427, 3.2.428, 3.2.429, 3.2.430, 3.2.431, 3.2.432, 3.2.433, 3.2.434, 3.2.435, 3.2.436, 3.2.437, 3.2.438, 3.2.439, 3.2.440, 3.2.441, 3.2.442, 3.2.443, 3.2.444, 3.2.445, 3.2.446, 3.2.447, 3.2.448, 3.2.449, 3.2.450, 3.2.451, 3.2.452, 3.2.453, 3.2.454, 3.2.455, 3.2.456, 3.2.457, 3.2.458, 3.2.459, 3.2.460, 3.2.461, 3.2.462, 3.2.463, 3.2.464, 3.2.465, 3.2.466, 3.2.467, 3.2.468, 3.2.469, 3.2.470, 3.2.471, 3.2.472, 3.2.473, 3.2.474, 3.2.475, 3.2.476, 3.2.477, 3.2.478, 3.2.479, 3.2.480, 3.2.481, 3.2.482, 3.2.483, 3.2.484, 3.2.485, 3.2.486, 3.2.487, 3.2.488, 3.2.489, 3.2.490, 3.2.491, 3.2.492, 3.2.493, 3.2.494, 3.2.495, 3.2.496, 3.2.497, 3.2.498, 3.2.499, 3.2.500, 3.2.501, 3.2.502, 3.2.503, 3.2.504, 3.2.505, 3.2.506, 3.2.507, 3.2.508, 3.2.509, 3.2.510, 3.2.511, 3.2.512, 3.2.513, 3.2.514, 3.2.515, 3.2.516, 3.2.517, 3.2.518, 3.2.519, 3.2.520, 3.2.521, 3.2.522, 3.2.523, 3.2.524, 3.2.525, 3.2.526, 3.2.527, 3.2.528, 3.2.529, 3.2.530, 3.2.531, 3.2.532, 3.2.533, 3.2.534, 3.2.535, 3.2.536, 3.2.537, 3.2.538, 3.2.539, 3.2.540, 3.2.541, 3.2.542, 3.2.543, 3.2.544, 3.2.545, 3.2.546, 3.2.547, 3.2.548, 3.2.549, 3.2.550, 3.2.551, 3.2.552, 3.2.553, 3.2.554, 3.2.555, 3.2.556, 3.2.557, 3.2.558, 3.2.559, 3.2.560, 3.2.561, 3.2.562, 3.2.563, 3.2.564, 3.2.565, 3.2.566, 3.2.567, 3.2.568, 3.2.569, 3.2.570, 3.2.571, 3.2.572, 3.2.573, 3.2.574, 3.2.575, 3.2.576, 3.2.577, 3.2.578, 3.2.579, 3.2.580, 3.2.581, 3.2.582, 3.2.583, 3.2.584, 3.2.585, 3.2.586, 3.2.587, 3.2.588, 3.2.589, 3.2.590, 3.2.591, 3.2.592, 3.2.593, 3.2.594, 3.2.595, 3.2.596, 3.2.597, 3.2.598, 3.2.599, 3.2.600, 3.2.601, 3.2.602, 3.2.603, 3.2.604, 3.2.605, 3.2.606, 3.2.607, 3.2.608, 3.2.609, 3.2.610, 3.2.611, 3.2.612, 3.2.613, 3.2.614, 3.2.615, 3.2.616, 3.2.617, 3.2.618, 3.2.619, 3.2.620, 3.2.621, 3.2.622, 3.2.623, 3.2.624, 3.2.625, 3.2.626, 3.2.627, 3.2.628, 3.2.629, 3.2.630, 3.2.631, 3.2.632, 3.2.633, 3.2.634, 3.2.635, 3.2.636, 3.2.637, 3.2.638, 3.2.639, 3.2.640, 3.2.641, 3.2.642, 3.2.643, 3.2.644, 3.2.645, 3.2.646, 3.2.647, 3.2.648, 3.2.649, 3.2.650, 3.2.651, 3.2.652, 3.2.653, 3.2.654, 3.2.655, 3.2.656, 3.2.657, 3.2.658, 3.2.659, 3.2.660, 3.2.661, 3.2.662, 3.2.663, 3.2.664, 3.2.665, 3.2.666, 3.2.667, 3.2.668, 3.2.669, 3.2.670, 3.2.671, 3.2.672, 3.2.673, 3.2.674, 3.2.675, 3.2.676, 3.2.677, 3.2.678, 3.2.679, 3.2.680, 3.2.681, 3.2.682, 3.2.683, 3.2.684, 3.2.685, 3.2.686, 3.2.687, 3.2.688, 3.2.689, 3.2.690, 3.2.691, 3.2.692, 3.2.693, 3.2.694, 3.2.695, 3.2.696, 3.2.697, 3.2.698, 3.2.699, 3.2.700, 3.2.701, 3.2.702, 3.2.703, 3.2.704, 3.2.705, 3.2.706, 3.2.707, 3.2.708, 3.2.709, 3.2.710, 3.2.711, 3.2.712, 3.2.713, 3.2.714, 3.2.715, 3.2.716, 3.2.717, 3.2.718, 3.2.719, 3.2.720, 3.2.721, 3.2.722, 3.2.723, 3.2.724, 3.2.725, 3.2.726, 3.2.727, 3.2.728, 3.2.729, 3.2.730, 3.2.731, 3.2.732, 3.2.733, 3.2.734, 3.2.735, 3.2.736, 3.2.737, 3.2.738, 3.2.739, 3.2.740, 3.2.741, 3.2.742, 3.2.743, 3.2.744, 3.2.745, 3.2.746, 3.2.747, 3.2.748, 3.2.749, 3.2.750, 3.2.751, 3.2.752, 3.2.753, 3.2.754, 3.2.755, 3.2.756, 3.2.757, 3.2.758, 3.2.759, 3.2.760, 3.2.761, 3.2.762, 3.2.763, 3.2.764, 3.2.765, 3.2.766, 3.2.767, 3.2.768, 3.2.769, 3.2.770, 3.2.771, 3.2.772, 3.2.773, 3.2.774, 3.2.775, 3.2.776, 3.2.777, 3.2.778, 3.2.779, 3.2.780, 3.2.781, 3.2.782, 3.2.783, 3.2.784, 3.2.785, 3.2.786, 3.2.787, 3.2.788, 3.2.789, 3.2.790, 3.2.791, 3.2.792, 3.2.793, 3.2.794, 3.2.795, 3.2.796, 3.2.797, 3.2.798, 3.2.799-р зүйлүүдийг зөрчөөгүй.

🏛️ ШҮҮХИЙН ШИЙДВЭР

• Өдөр: 2025-02-03, Дугаар: 149/ШШ2025/00056 Захиргааны хэргийн анхан шатны шүүх нэхэмжлэлийг бүхэлд нь хэрэгсэхгүй болгосон.

📚 ҮНДЭСЛЭЛ

• Газрын тухай хуулийн 3.1.2-т "Газрын нэгдмэл сан" гэж Монгол Улсын нутаг дэвсгэр дэх бүх газар болон түүний хэвлийн баялгийг хэлнэ.
• Газрын тухай хуулийн 3.1.5-д "Газар эзэмших" гэж хууль тогтоомжид заасны дагуу гэрээний үндсэн дээр газар ашиглах эрхийг хэлнэ.
• Газрын тухай хуулийн 3.2.1-д "Газар эзэмших эрхийн гэрчилгээ" нь тухайн газрыг эзэмших эрхийг баталгаажуулсан баримт бичиг.
• Захиргааны ерөнхий хуулийн 47.1-д захиргааны акт нь хууль бус бол хүчингүй болгоно.
• Захиргааны ерөнхий хуулийн 47.2-т захиргааны акт нь хууль ёсны байсан ч нөхцөл байдал өөрчлөгдсөн тохиолдолд хүчингүй болгож болно.
• Сэлэнгэ аймгийн Засаг даргын 2024 оны А/165 дугаар захирамж нь хууль зүйн үндэслэлтэй байна.
• Нэхэмжлэгчийн газар эзэмших эрхийн гэрчилгээг хүчингүй болгосон нь хууль бус гэж үзэх үндэслэлгүй.